Lizzy Caplan

Carol

Antony Starr

Mark

Cleopatra Coleman

Miss Devine

Woody Norman

Peter

Luke Busey

Brian

Aleksandra Dragova

The Girl (Sarah)

Jay Rincon

Principal

Anton Kottas

Timothy

Steffanie Sampson

Brian's Mom

Jivko Mihaylov

Kevin (Bunny Mask)

Iliyan Nikolov

Lucious (Cat Mask)

Aleksander Asparuhov

Sean (Pig Mask)

Victoria Velikova

Princess

Kate Nichols

Princess' Mom

Leah-Felicity Bay

Katie D.

James Robinson

Ryan G.

Olivia Sussman

Young Sarah (voice)

Debra Wilson

Monster Sarah (voice)