Julia Garner

Justine

Josh Brolin

Archer

Alden Ehrenreich

Paul

Austin Abrams

James

Benedict Wong

Marcus

Amy Madigan

Gladys

Cary Christopher

Alex

Toby Huss

Captain Ed

Whitmer Thomas

Alex's Dad

Callie Schuttera

Alex's Mom

June Diane Raphael

Donna

Scarlett Sher

Narrator (voice)

Jason Turner

Counselor

Anny Jules

Parent #1

Ali Burch

Parent #2

Michael Gene Conti

Parent #3

Eric Jepson

Officer

Ronny Mathew

Liquor Store Clerk

Melissa Ponzio

Archer's Wife

Luke Speakman

Matthew

Aaron Quick Nelson

Foreman

Sara Paxton

Erica

Justin Long

Gary

Mohammed Fahmy

Pawn Broker

Clayton Farris

Terry

Carrie Gibson

Marge

Ashley Ames

Bystander

Fidelus Singleton

Gas Station Clerk

Sarah Kopkin

Driver

Arya Posey

Lisa

Carl Kennedy

Grownup

Robert Hendren

Detective

Aubrey Brockwell

Classmate (uncredited)

Keith Paul Carpenter

Frantic Parent (uncredited)