Archie Yates

Max Mercer

Ellie Kemper

Pam McKenzie

Rob Delaney

Jeff McKenzie

Aisling Bea

Carol Mercer

Devin Ratray

Buzz McCallister

Pete Holmes

Uncle Blake

Kenan Thompson

Gavin Washington

Timothy Simons

Hunter

Chris Parnell

Uncle Stu

Ally Maki

Mei

Katie Beth Hall

Abby McKenzie

Max Ivutin

Chris McKenzie

Andy Daly

Mike Mercer

Madeline Holliday

Katie Mercer

Mikey Day

Priest

Jordan Carlos

Clem Breckin

Esther Povitsky

Daisy Breckin

Marty Adams

Annoying Passenger

Jim Rash

Bell Choir Leader

Catherine Cohen

Mrs. Claus

Amy Okuda

Ticketing Agent

Bronwen Mantel

Barbara

Peter Schoelier

Herman

Tristan D. Lalla

Orderly

Nancy Helms

Enthusiastic Orderly

Gayle Garfinkle

Old Lady Coven

Jane Gilchrist

Old Lady Coven

Hazel Gorin

Old Lady Coven

Cara Ricketts

Aunt Beth

Aiden Wang

Ollie

Allan Wang

Ollie

Amadeo Correia

Young Chris McKenzie

Aron Benali

Ryan

Emilio Williams

Stu's Child #1

Sylvia Simonetti

Stu's Child #2

Osias Reid

Burke Son #1

Dylan Eugene Olivier

Burke Son #2

Deryk Eugene Olivier

Burke Son #3

Jayne Eastwood

Grandma (uncredited)